X11/SC15/TG17/1997-5
Error handling corrections, Version 5

Discussed in: SC15/TG17 Process Control
Proposer: David J. Marcus
Sponsor: Wally Fort
Superseded by: X11/SC15/TG17/1998-2, Error handling corrections, version 6
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1998-5, Error handling corrections, version 7

Submitted: 13 Aug 1997
Description:
SEPT 97: SC15/TG17 amends and recommends as a replacement SC15 type B 4-0-2. SC15 makes it so 21-0-3.
Published:
Aug 1997

Votes

• In Chicago, Illinois, on 4 June 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/1995-64, Error Handling Corrections, version 1 as a Type C document of Subcommittee 15 passed by a vote of 16 in favor, none opposed and 3 abstaining.
  
• In New Orleans, Louisiana, on 26 October 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1995-38, Error Handling Corrections, version 2 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/1995-64, Error Handling Corrections, version 1 passed by a vote of 17 in favor, 2 opposed and 6 abstaining.
  
• In San Diego, California, on 19 March 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/TG17/1997-1, Error handling corrections, version 4 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/TG17/1996-5, Error handling corrections, version 3 passed by a vote of 23 in favor, none opposed and 3 abstaining.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept this document as a Type B document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/TG17/1997-1, Error handling corrections, version 4 passed by a vote of 21 in favor, none opposed and 3 abstaining.
  

X11/SC15/1997-7
First line format, Version 10

Discussed in: SC15 Programming Structures
Proposer: Thomas C. Salander
Sponsor: Wally Fort
Superseded by: X11/1997-25, First line format, Version 11

Submitted: 13 Aug 1997
Description:
SEPT 97: Passed to MDC type A 22-0-3.
Published:
Aug 1997

Votes

• In Coraopolis, Pennsylvania, on 5 February 1992, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to remand X11/SC15/1991-13, First Line Format to Task Group (automatic Type C status) passed 20 in favor and 3 opposed.
  
• In Phoenix, Arizona, on 14 June 1992, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1991-13, First Line Format as amended as a Type C document of Subcommittee 15 passed 20 in favor and 4 opposed.
  
• In Portland, Oregon, on 28 February 1993, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/TG8/1993-1, First Line Format, version 2 as amended (also known as X11/SC15/TG9/93-1) as a Type B document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/TG8/1992-1, First Line Format, version 1 passed by a vote of 13 in favor, 7 opposed and 3 abstaining.
  
• In Washington, District of Columbia, on 20 June 1993, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/TG9/1993-4, First Line Format, version 3 as amended as a Type A document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/TG8/1993-1, First Line Format, version 2 passed by a vote of 27 in favor, none opposed and 3 abstaining.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 4 June 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/TG9/1995-3, First Line Format, version 4 as amended as a Type B document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/TG9/1993-4, First Line Format, version 3 passed by a vote of 9 in favor, 8 opposed and 4 abstaining.
  
• In New Orleans, Louisiana, on 26 October 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/TG9/1995-104, First Line Format, version 5 as amended as a Type B document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/TG9/1995-3, First Line Format, version 4 passed by a vote of 20 in favor, none opposed and 5 abstaining.
  
• In Boston, Massachusetts, on 23 March 1996, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/TG9/1996-4, VA First Line Format as amended as a Type B document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/TG9/1995-104, First Line Format, version 5 and X11/SC15/1995-40, First Line Format, version 6 passed by a vote of 15 in favor, none opposed and 7 abstaining.
  
• In San Diego, California, on 19 March 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1997-1, First line format, version 9 as a Type A document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/1996-20, First line format, version 8 passed by a vote of 20 in favor, none opposed and 6 abstaining.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before the full MDC to accept this document as a Type A extension of the MUMPS Development Committee superseding X11/SC15/1997-1, First line format, version 9 passed by a vote of 22 in favor, none opposed and 3 abstaining.
  

X11/SC15/1997-11
Minutes SC15 September 1996 Revised

Discussed in: SC15 Programming Structures
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 14 Aug 1997

Published:
Aug 1997

Vote

• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept this document as corrected superseding X11/SC15/1996-22, Minutes Subcommittee 15, September 1996 passed without dissent.
  

X11/SC15/1997-8
Minutes SC15 March 1997

Discussed in: SC15 Programming Structures
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 14 Aug 1997

Published:
Aug 1997

Vote

• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept this document passed without dissent.
  

X11/SC15/TG17/1997-7
I[f], E[lse] and $T[est]

Discussed in: SC15/TG17 Process Control
Proposer: Michael Bundy
Sponsor: Arthur B. Smith
Superseded by: X11/SC15/TG17/1997-8, I[f], T[hen] and E[lse]
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1998-3, I[f], T[hen] and E[lse], version 2
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1998-7, I[f], T[hen] and E[lse], version 3
Superseded by: X11/1998-31, I[f], T[hen] and E[lse], version 4

Submitted: 14 Aug 1997
Description:
EMAIL of Bundy letter about IF/ELSE/$T. 14 AUG 97. SEPT 97: SC15/TG17 agreed to advance X11/SC15/TG17/97-8 rather than this proposal.
Published:
Aug 1997

X11/SC15/1997-13
Fix algoref, Version 4

Discussed in: SC15 Programming Structures
Proposer: Bernard E. Bishop
Sponsor: Bernard E. Bishop
Superseded by: X11/1998-5, Fix algoref, version 5

Submitted: 15 Aug 1997
Description:
SEPT 97: accepted as MDC type A 24-0-1.
Published:
Aug 1997

Votes

• In Boston, Massachusetts, on 23 March 1996, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1996-10, Fix algoref as a Type C document of Subcommittee 15 passed by a vote of 20 in favor, none opposed and 2 abstaining.
  
• In Toronto, Canada, on 29 September 1996, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1996-10, Fix algoref as a Type B document of Subcommittee 15 passed by a vote of 29 in favor, none opposed and 1 abstaining.
  
• In San Diego, California, on 19 March 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1997-2, Fix algoref, version 3 as a Type A document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/1996-15, Fix algoref, version 2 passed by a vote of 24 in favor, none opposed and 2 abstaining.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before the full MDC to accept this document as a Type A extension of the MUMPS Development Committee superseding X11/SC15/1997-2, Fix algoref, version 3 passed by a vote of 24 in favor, none opposed and 1 abstaining.
  

X11/SC13/1997-11
Local variables in ^$J[ob], Version 6

Discussed in: SC13 Data Management & Manipulation
Proposer: Bernard E. Bishop
Sponsor: Rod Dorman
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1998-3, Local variables in ^$J[ob], version 7
Superseded by: X11/1998-29, Local variables in ^$J[ob], version 8

Submitted: 15 Aug 1997
Description:
Local Variables in ^$JOB Sept 97: Motion printed on the document is for SC13 to accept as a type A, but the superseded document is already a type A. SC13/TG13 recommends acceptance as replacement SC13 type A, also superseding Unsubscripted $ORDER X11/SC13/97-4, 10-0-2. SC13 makes it so 15-2-2.
Published:
Aug 1997

Votes

• In San Diego, California, on 25 January 1991, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept X11/SC1/1990-105, ORDER, Local as a Type C document of Subcommittee 1 passed by a vote of 34 in favor, 3 opposed and 1 abstaining.
  
• In Coraopolis, Pennsylvania, on 5 February 1992, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC13/1991-29, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 2 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC1/1991-51, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 1 passed by a vote of 27 in favor, 2 opposed and 2 abstaining.
  
• In Phoenix, Arizona, on 14 June 1992, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC13/1992-11, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 3 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC13/1991-29, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 2 passed by a vote of 17 in favor, 1 opposed and 2 abstaining.
  
• In Portland, Oregon, on 28 February 1993, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC13/1991-29, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 2 (demotion) as a Type B document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC1/1991-51, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 1 passed 20 in favor and 3 opposed.
  
• In Portland, Oregon, on 28 February 1993, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC13/1992-53, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 4 (demotion) as a Type B document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC13/1992-11, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 3 passed 20 in favor and 3 opposed.
  
• In Portland, Oregon, on 28 February 1993, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC13/1993-18, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 6 (demotion) as a Type B document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC13/1993-15, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 5 passed 20 in favor and 3 opposed.
  
• In Houston, Texas, on 27 February 1994, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC13/TG13/1994-1, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 10 as amended as a Type B document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC13/1993-61, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 9 passed by a vote of 7 in favor, 3 opposed and 2 abstaining.
  
• In Reno, Nevada, on 12 June 1994, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC13/TG13/1994-4, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 11 as a Type A document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC13/TG13/1994-1, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 10 passed by a vote of 17 in favor, 7 opposed and 1 abstaining.
  
• In Reno, Nevada, on 12 June 1994, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC15/1994-24, Local Variables in ^$J[ob], version 1 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 13 passed by a vote of 15 in favor, 8 opposed and 5 abstaining.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 4 June 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC13/1995-13, Local Variables in ^$J[ob], version 3 as a Type A document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC13/1994-47, Local Variables in ^$J[ob], version 2 failed by a vote of 9 in favor, 14 opposed and 2 abstaining.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 4 June 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC13/TG13/1995-3, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 13 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC13/TG13/1994-8, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 12 passed by a vote of 15 in favor, 7 opposed and 3 abstaining.
  
• In New Orleans, Louisiana, on 26 October 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC13/TG13/1995-5, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 14 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC13/TG13/1995-3, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 13 passed by a vote of 11 in favor, 8 opposed and 5 abstaining.
  
• In Boston, Massachusetts, on 23 March 1996, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC13/1996-1, Local Variables in ^$J[ob], version 4 as amended as a Type A document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC13/1994-16, ssvn for Local Variable, version 2 and X11/SC13/1995-13, Local Variables in ^$J[ob], version 3 passed by a vote of 10 in favor, 2 opposed and 5 abstaining.
  
• In Toronto, Canada, on 29 September 1996, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to remand X11/SC13/TG13/1996-4, $O[rder], unsubscripted, version 16 to task group 13 superseding X11/SC13/TG13/1996-1, Un-Subscripted $O[rder], version 15 passed 18 in favor and 2 opposed.
  
• In San Diego, California, on 19 March 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC13/TG13/1997-1, Order, unsubscripted, version 17 as amended by Subcommittee 13 at its previous meeting as a Type A document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC13/TG13/1996-4, $O[rder], unsubscripted, version 16 failed by a vote of 2 in favor, 17 opposed and 2 abstaining.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept this document as a Type A document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC13/1996-1, Local Variables in ^$J[ob], version 4 and X11/SC13/TG13/1997-4, $O[rder], unsubscripted, Version 18 passed by a vote of 15 in favor, 2 opposed and 2 abstaining.
  

X11/SC13/1997-10
N[ew] $R[eference], Version 2

Discussed in: SC13 Data Management & Manipulation
Proposer: Bernard E. Bishop
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1998-4, N[ew] $R[eference], version 3
Superseded by: X11/1998-30, N[ew] $R[eference], version 4

Submitted: 15 Aug 1997
Description:
SEPT 97: motion to accept as SC13 type A passed 11-5-3
Published:
Aug 1997

Votes

• In Minneapolis, Minnesota, on 21 October 1992, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/TG9/1992-3, N[ew] svn, version 2 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/TG9/1992-2, N[ew] svn, version 1 failed by a vote of 7 in favor, 14 opposed and 5 abstaining.
  
• In San Diego, California, on 19 March 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept X11/SC13/1997-3, N[ew] $R[eference] as a Type B document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC13/TG10/1993-4, N[ew] svn $R[eference] passed by a vote of 12 in favor, none opposed and 4 abstaining.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept this document as a Type A document of Subcommittee 13 superseding X11/SC13/1997-3, N[ew] $R[eference] passed by a vote of 11 in favor, 5 opposed and 3 abstaining.
  

X11/SC15/1997-12
Routine indirection, Version 7

Discussed in: SC15 Programming Structures
Proposer: Bernard E. Bishop
Sponsor: David J. Whitten
Superseded by: X11/SC15/TG16/1998-2, Generic indirection
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1998-11, Generic indirection, version 2

Submitted: 15 Aug 1997
Description:
SEPT 97: SC15/TG16 recommends elevation to SC15 type A 5-0-3. SC15 failed to elevate to type A 7-14-2.
Published:
Aug 1997

Votes

• In Dublin, Ireland, on 25 October 1993, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1993-36, Routine Indirection, version 1 as a Type C document of Subcommittee 15 passed by a vote of 7 in favor, 6 opposed and 3 abstaining.
  
• In Reno, Nevada, on 12 June 1994, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1994-22, Routine Indirection, version 2 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/1993-36, Routine Indirection, version 1 passed by a vote of 20 in favor, none opposed and 8 abstaining.
  
• In Albuquerque, New Mexico, on 29 January 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1994-37, Routine Indirection, version 3 as a Type A document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/1994-22, Routine Indirection, version 2 failed by a vote of 11 in favor, 6 opposed and 6 abstaining.
  
• In Albuquerque, New Mexico, on 29 January 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1994-37, Routine Indirection, version 3 as a Type A document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/1994-22, Routine Indirection, version 2 failed by a vote of 5 in favor, 13 opposed and 6 abstaining.
  
• In New Orleans, Louisiana, on 26 October 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1994-37, Routine Indirection, version 3 (demotion) as a Type C document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/1994-22, Routine Indirection, version 2 failed without dissent.
  
• In New Orleans, Louisiana, on 26 October 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to remand X11/SC15/1994-37, Routine Indirection, version 3 to Task Group superseding X11/SC15/1994-22, Routine Indirection, version 2 passed without dissent.
  
• In New Orleans, Louisiana, on 26 October 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to rescind X11/SC15/1994-37, Routine Indirection, version 3 superseding X11/SC15/1994-22, Routine Indirection, version 2 failed 5 in favor and 14 opposed.
  
• In Boston, Massachusetts, on 23 March 1996, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1996-2, Routine Indirection, version 4 as a Type A document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/1994-37, Routine Indirection, version 3 passed by a vote of 15 in favor, 3 opposed and 5 abstaining.
  
• In Toronto, Canada, on 29 September 1996, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to recommend X11/SC15/1996-16, Routine indirection, version 5 for consideration as MDC Type A superseding X11/SC15/1996-2, Routine Indirection, version 4 passed without dissent.
  
• In San Diego, California, on 19 March 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1997-3, Routine indirection, version 6 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/1996-16, Routine indirection, version 5 passed by a vote of 12 in favor, 6 opposed and 7 abstaining.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept this document as a Type A document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/1997-3, Routine indirection, version 6 failed by a vote of 7 in favor, 14 opposed and 2 abstaining.
  

X11/SC15/1997-14
expritem indirection, Version 3

Discussed in: SC15 Programming Structures
Proposer: Mo Cheng
Sponsor: Bernard E. Bishop
Superseded by: X11/SC15/TG16/1998-2, Generic indirection
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1998-11, Generic indirection, version 2

Submitted: 15 Aug 1997
Description:
SEPT 97: SC15/TG16 recommends elevation to SC15 type A 7-0-1. SC15 failed to elevate to type A 6-15-2.
Published:
Aug 1997

Votes

• In Houston, Texas, on 27 February 1994, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1994-2, expritem Indirection, version 1 as a Type C document of Subcommittee 15 passed by a vote of 15 in favor, 6 opposed and 4 abstaining.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 4 June 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept X11/SC15/1995-9, expritem Indirection, version 2 as amended as a Type B document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/1994-2, expritem Indirection, version 1 passed by a vote of 17 in favor, 4 opposed and 2 abstaining.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept this document as a Type A document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/1995-9, expritem Indirection, version 2 failed by a vote of 6 in favor, 15 opposed and 2 abstaining.
  

X11/1996-19
Draft letter to Henry Heffernan 23 March 1996

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Administrative

Submitted: 8 Sep 1997
Description:
Draft document addressed to HHeffernan from Ed de Moel, MDC chairman, dated 23 March 1996. Document is reaction/response to several HH documents. Document was accepted by full MDC on March 23, 1996.

Vote

• In Boston, Massachusetts, on 23 March 1996, a motion before the full MDC to accept this document as draft response passed 23 in favor and none opposed.
  

X11/SC12/TG2/1997-3
Minutes SC12/TG2 March 1997

Discussed in: SC12/TG2 Internationalisation
Proposer: Kate M. Schell
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 9 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC12/TG2/1997-4
Minutes SC12/TG2 September 1997

Discussed in: SC12/TG2 Internationalisation
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Sponsor: Kate M. Schell
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 9 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC12/TG7/1996-3
Minutes SC12/TG7 September 1997

Discussed in: SC12/TG7 Security
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 9 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC12/TG7/1997-1
Minutes SC12/TG7 March 1997

Discussed in: SC12/TG7 Security
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 9 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC12/TG7/1997-3
Minutes SC12/TG7 September 1997

Discussed in: SC12/TG7 Security
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 9 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC12/1997-10
ssvn for user/group ID, Version 6

Discussed in: SC12 Environment
Proposer: Lawrence A. Ruh
Sponsor: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Superseded by: X11/SC12/1997-11, ssvn for user/group ID, Version 7
Superseded by: X11/1998-8, ssvn for user and group ID, version 8

Submitted: 9 Oct 1997
Description:
SEPT 97: SC12/TG7 recommends acceptance as SC type A with editorial corrections 3-0-1. SC12 makes it so 6-2-9.
Published:
Nov 1997

Votes

• In Washington, District of Columbia, on 20 June 1993, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to remand X11/SC12/TG7/1992-1, Write Once Security ssvn to Task Group 7 passed without dissent.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 4 June 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to accept X11/SC12/TG7/1995-1, ssvn for User and Group ID, version 1 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 12 superseding X11/SC12/TG7/1992-1, Write Once Security ssvn passed by a vote of 2 in favor, 1 opposed and 4 abstaining.
  
• In Boston, Massachusetts, on 23 March 1996, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to accept X11/SC12/TG7/1996-1, ssvn for User and Group ID, version 2 as amended as a Type A document of Subcommittee 12 superseding X11/SC12/TG7/1995-1, ssvn for User and Group ID, version 1 passed by a vote of 4 in favor, none opposed and 7 abstaining.
  
• In Toronto, Canada, on 29 September 1996, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to remand X11/SC12/1996-11, ssvn for user/group ID, version 4 to task group 7 superseding X11/SC12/1996-8, ssvn for user/group ID, version 3 passed without dissent.
  
• In San Diego, California, on 19 March 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to accept X11/1997-8, ssvn for user/group ID, version 5 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 12 superseding X11/SC12/1996-11, ssvn for user/group ID, version 4 passed by a vote of 7 in favor, 4 opposed and 3 abstaining.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to accept this document as amended as a Type A document of Subcommittee 12 superseding X11/1997-8, ssvn for user/group ID, version 5 passed by a vote of 6 in favor, 2 opposed and 9 abstaining.
  

X11/SC12/TG9/1996-9
Minutes SC12/TG9 September 1996

Discussed in: SC12/TG9 General Device Issues
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 10 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC12/TG9/1997-2
Minutes SC12/TG9 March 1997

Discussed in: SC12/TG9 General Device Issues
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 10 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC12/TG9/1997-11
Minutes SC12/TG9 September 1997

Discussed in: SC12/TG9 General Device Issues
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 10 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC12/TG10/1997-7
Minutes SC12/TG10 September 1997

Discussed in: SC12/TG10 Model
Proposer: Frans S.C. Witte
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 14 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC12/1997-12
Minutes SC12 September 1997

Discussed in: SC12 Environment
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Sponsor: Lawrence A. Ruh
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 14 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

Vote

• In Buckhead, Georgia, on 22 March 1998, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to accept this document as amended passed without dissent.
  

X11/SC13/TG2/1997-3
Minutes SC13/TG2 September 1997

Discussed in: SC13/TG2 String Handling
Proposer: Alexander Mikhaylov
Sponsor: David J. Whitten
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 14 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC13/TG3/1997-3
Minutes SC13/TG3 September 1997

Discussed in: SC13/TG3 Set Positional
Proposer: Alexander Mikhaylov
Sponsor: David J. Whitten
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 14 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC13/TG5/1997-3
Minutes SC13/TG5 September 1997

Discussed in: SC13/TG5 Mathematics
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Sponsor: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 14 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC13/TG13/1997-5
Minutes SC13/TG13 September 1997

Discussed in: SC13/TG13 Traversal Of Data Structures
Proposer: Rod Dorman
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 14 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC15/TG9/1997-6
Minutes SC15/TG9 September 1997

Discussed in: SC15/TG9 Routine Structure
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Sponsor: Bernard E. Bishop
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 14 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC16/1997-8
Minutes SC16 March 1997

Discussed in: SC16 Object Oriented Language
Proposer: R. Chris Richardson
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 14 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/TG8/1996-2
Minutes MDC/TG8 March 1996

Discussed in: TG8 Internal Procedures
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC12/1997-13
Scope of work SC12

Discussed in: SC12 Environment
Proposer: Lawrence A. Ruh
Standing document

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997
Description:
SEPT 97: amended and accepted as standing document.
Published:
Nov 1997

Vote

• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before the full MDC to accept this document as a standing document passed by voice vote.
  

X11/SC12/TG2/1997-5
Scope of work SC12/TG2 1997

Discussed in: SC12/TG2 Internationalisation
Proposer: Kate M. Schell
Withdrawn

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

Vote

• In Minneapolis, Minnesota, on 21 October 1992, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to accept X11/SC12/TG2/1992-11, Internationalization Project, version 2 as amended superseding X11/SC12/TG2/1992-8, Internationalization Project, version 1 passed 6 in favor and none opposed.
  

X11/SC12/TG7/1997-2
Scope of work SC12/TG7

Discussed in: SC12/TG7 Security
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Standing document

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC12/TG9/1997-10
Scope of work SC12/TG9 1997

Discussed in: SC12/TG9 General Device Issues
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Standing document

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC13/TG2/1997-4
Scope of work SC13/TG2 1997

Discussed in: SC13/TG2 String Handling
Proposer: David J. Whitten
Standing document

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC13/TG3/1997-4
Scope of work SC13/TG3

Discussed in: SC13/TG3 Set Positional
Proposer: David J. Whitten
Standing document

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC13/TG15/1997-1
Scope of work SC13/TG15 1997

Discussed in: SC13/TG15 Local Variable Storage
Proposer: Frederick D.S. Marshall
Withdrawn

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997
Mar 1998

X11/SC15/TG9/1997-7
Scope of work SC15/TG9 1997

Discussed in: SC15/TG9 Routine Structure
Proposer: Bernard E. Bishop
Standing document

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC15/TG17/1997-8
I[f], T[hen] and E[lse]

Discussed in: SC15/TG17 Process Control
Proposer: Bernard E. Bishop
Sponsor: Wally Fort
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1998-3, I[f], T[hen] and E[lse], version 2
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1998-7, I[f], T[hen] and E[lse], version 3
Superseded by: X11/1998-31, I[f], T[hen] and E[lse], version 4

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997
Description:
SEPT 97: SC15/TG17 recommends acceptance as SC15 type B 7-0-3. SC15 makes it so 15-4-4.
Published:
Nov 1997

Vote

• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 15 to accept this document as a Type B document of Subcommittee 15 superseding X11/SC15/TG17/1997-7, I[f], E[lse] and $T[est] passed by a vote of 15 in favor, 4 opposed and 4 abstaining.
  

X11/1997-21
Budget review

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Arthur B. Smith
Administrative

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/TG8/1997-7
Appeals procedure 1997

Discussed in: TG8 Internal Procedures
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Standing document

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997
Description:
MDC Appeals Procedure. Consolidates X11/96-21, X11/TG8/96-3, and X11/TG8/96-5. Sept 97: MDC approves as standing document 23-0-2.
Published:
Nov 1997

Votes

• In Portland, Oregon, on 28 February 1993, a motion before the full MDC to accept X11/TG8/1992-28, Appeals Procedure, version 5 as a standing document superseding X11/TG8/1992-23, Appeals Procedure, version 4 passed by a vote of 33 in favor, none opposed and 4 abstaining.
  
• In New Orleans, Louisiana, on 26 October 1995, a motion before the full MDC to accept X11/1995-127, Appeals Procedure 1995, version 2 as amended superseding X11/TG8/1992-28, Appeals Procedure, version 5 and X11/TG8/1995-4, Appeals Procedure 1995, version 1 passed 29 in favor and none opposed.
  
• In Boston, Massachusetts, on 23 March 1996, a motion before the full MDC to accept X11/TG8/1996-3, Appeals Application as a standing document passed 25 in favor and none opposed.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before the full MDC to accept this document as a standing document superseding X11/TG8/1996-5, Appeal Form, version 2, X11/TG8/1996-3, Appeals Application and X11/1996-21, Appeals procedure 96 passed by a vote of 23 in favor, none opposed and 2 abstaining.
  

X11/SC12/1997-11
ssvn for user/group ID, Version 7

Discussed in: SC12 Environment
Proposer: Lawrence A. Ruh
Sponsor: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Superseded by: X11/1998-8, ssvn for user and group ID, version 8

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997
Description:
MAR 98: SC12/TG7 recommends elevation to MDC type A without dissent. MDC makes it so 19-0-6.
Published:
Nov 1997

Votes

• In Washington, District of Columbia, on 20 June 1993, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to remand X11/SC12/TG7/1992-1, Write Once Security ssvn to Task Group 7 passed without dissent.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 4 June 1995, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to accept X11/SC12/TG7/1995-1, ssvn for User and Group ID, version 1 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 12 superseding X11/SC12/TG7/1992-1, Write Once Security ssvn passed by a vote of 2 in favor, 1 opposed and 4 abstaining.
  
• In Boston, Massachusetts, on 23 March 1996, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to accept X11/SC12/TG7/1996-1, ssvn for User and Group ID, version 2 as amended as a Type A document of Subcommittee 12 superseding X11/SC12/TG7/1995-1, ssvn for User and Group ID, version 1 passed by a vote of 4 in favor, none opposed and 7 abstaining.
  
• In Toronto, Canada, on 29 September 1996, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to remand X11/SC12/1996-11, ssvn for user/group ID, version 4 to task group 7 superseding X11/SC12/1996-8, ssvn for user/group ID, version 3 passed without dissent.
  
• In San Diego, California, on 19 March 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to accept X11/1997-8, ssvn for user/group ID, version 5 as a Type B document of Subcommittee 12 superseding X11/SC12/1996-11, ssvn for user/group ID, version 4 passed by a vote of 7 in favor, 4 opposed and 3 abstaining.
  
• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to accept X11/SC12/1997-10, ssvn for user/group ID, Version 6 as amended as a Type A document of Subcommittee 12 superseding X11/1997-8, ssvn for user/group ID, version 5 passed by a vote of 6 in favor, 2 opposed and 9 abstaining.
  
• In Buckhead, Georgia, on 22 March 1998, a motion before the full MDC to accept this document as a Type A extension of the MUMPS Development Committee superseding X11/SC12/1997-10, ssvn for user/group ID, Version 6 passed by a vote of 19 in favor, none opposed and 6 abstaining.
  
• In Buckhead, Georgia, on 22 March 1998, a motion before Subcommittee 12 to recommend this document to MDC for consideration as MDC Type A superseding X11/SC12/1997-10, ssvn for user/group ID, Version 6 passed without dissent.
  

X11/1997-24
Comments by David Marcus August 1997

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: David J. Marcus
Sponsor: Arthur B. Smith
Administrative

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997
Description:
Comments by David Marcus concerning several documents in the August 1997 mailing.
Published:
Nov 1997

X11/TG6/1997-1
X11.1 draft Standard, Version 12

Discussed in: TG6 Standards Preparation
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Sponsor: Frederick D.S. Marshall
Discussion

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/1997-26
Metric units policy, Version 2

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Arthur B. Smith
Standing document

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997
Description:
Metric Units Policy. Approved by MDC as standing document 9-27-97. Sent to ANSI 10-16-97.
Published:
Nov 1997

Vote

• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before the full MDC to accept X11/1997-5, Metric units policy as a standing document passed by a vote of 23 in favor, none opposed and 2 abstaining.
  

X11/1997-27
Document retention policy, Version 2

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Arthur B. Smith
Standing document

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997
Description:
Document retention policy. Approved by MDC as standing document 9-27-97. Sent to ANSI 10-16-97.
Published:
Nov 1997

Vote

• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before the full MDC to accept X11/1997-6, Document retention policy as a standing document passed by a vote of 23 in favor, none opposed and 2 abstaining.
  

X11/SC13/1997-13
Scope of work SC13 1997

Discussed in: SC13 Data Management & Manipulation
Proposer: Daniel Bormann
Standing document

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997
Description:
SEPT 97: accepted as standing document.
Published:
Nov 1997

Vote

• In Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1997, a motion before the full MDC to accept this document as a standing document superseding X11/SC13/1994-20, Scope of Work Subcommittee 13 passed by voice vote.
  

X11/SC12/TG14/1997-4
Minutes SC12/TG14 September 1997

Discussed in: SC12/TG14 xxx
Proposer: Frederick L. Hiltz
Sponsor: George K. Yenoki
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC15/TG16/1997-2
Minutes SC15/TG16 September 1997

Discussed in: SC15/TG16 Indirection
Proposer: Frederick L. Hiltz
Sponsor: David J. Whitten
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 16 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

X11/SC13/1997-12
Minutes SC13 September 1997

Discussed in: SC13 Data Management & Manipulation
Proposer: R. Chris Richardson
Sponsor: Daniel Bormann
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 21 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997

Vote

• In Buckhead, Georgia, on 22 March 1998, a motion before Subcommittee 13 to accept this document passed without dissent.
  

X11/SC16/TG1/1997-3
Minutes SC16/TG1 September 1997

Discussed in: SC16/TG1 Goals for Object Oriented Language
Proposer: Frederick D.S. Marshall
Sponsor: Jamie L. Crumley
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 21 Oct 1997

Published:
Nov 1997