X11.1/1987-8
Extend the Scope of the I[f], E[lse] and F[or] Commands

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Richard Bianchi
Superseded

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Extended scoping of the IF, ELSE, and FOR commands. To provide a simple system of expanded scoping, so as to allow the IF, ELSE, and FOR commands an ability to extend beyond, or to be contained within a line. Discussed at the June 87 meeting. Superseded by X11.1.1/85-8
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87. Post mtg mailing July 87.

X11/1987-4A
Type A Release Format

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Charles S. Volkstorf
Superseded by: X11/1988-21, Type A and B Proposal Format
Superseded by: X11/1991-24, Proposal Format, version 2
Superseded by: X11/TG8/1993-11, Proposal Format 1993, version 3
Superseded by: X11/1995-129, Proposal Format 1993, version 4

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Suggestions for a complete, structured format for both recording and developing proposals. Discussed at SC1 meeting June 87.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87. Post mtg July 87.

MDC-11
First Line Convention, version 1

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Harlan M. Stenn
Superseded

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Proposal for the format of the first line of a routine. Dated Oct 7, 1986. Superseded by X11.1.3/86-01
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87.

MDC-31
Error Trap Mechanism

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Harlan M. Stenn
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1988-44, Error Processing, version 8
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1989-7, Alternative Error Trapping
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-2, Error Processing, version 10
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-13, Error Processing, version 11
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-75, Error Processing, version 12
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-43, Error Processing, version 13
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-55, Error Processing, version 14
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-81, Error Processing, version 15
Superseded by: X11/SC15/TG1/1991-1, Error Processing, version 16
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1991-16, Error Processing, version 17B
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-3, Error Processing, version 18
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-19, Error Processing, version 19
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-27, Error Processing, version 20
Superseded by: X11/1993-5, Error Processing, version 21
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1987
Description:
A comprehensive error trapping facility for MUMPS. Dated May 12, 1987. This version 5 supersedes X11/SC1/TG5/86-1. Superseded by X11/SC1/TG5/87-1.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87.

MDC-32
Subtree Copying, version 1

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Berend Franken
Superseded by: X11/1990-3, M[erge] Command, version 2
Superseded by: X11/1992-52, M[erge] Command, version 3
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Discussion of subtree copying from Europe, dated February 25, 1987. Superseded by X11/SC1/TG4/87-2.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87.

MDC-33
Error Trapping and Processing

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Berend Franken
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-2, Error Processing, version 10
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-13, Error Processing, version 11
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-75, Error Processing, version 12
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-43, Error Processing, version 13
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-55, Error Processing, version 14
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-81, Error Processing, version 15
Superseded by: X11/SC15/TG1/1991-1, Error Processing, version 16
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1991-16, Error Processing, version 17B
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-3, Error Processing, version 18
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-19, Error Processing, version 19
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-27, Error Processing, version 20
Superseded by: X11/1993-5, Error Processing, version 21
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Discussion of a need for a mechanism for trapping errors and/or exceptions. Superseded by X11.1.1/85-22
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87.

X11.1/1987-6
Device Handling, version 1.4

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Superseded by: X11/1989-4, Device Handling, version 1.8
Superseded by: X11/1989-14, Device Handling, version 2
Superseded by: X11/1992-46, Device Handling, version 3
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1987
Description:
This proposal involves the extension of the READ, WRITE, and USE commands and the definition of a new system variable, $KEY. These extensions will help to standardize device interfacing.
Comments:
This is proposal 16.1, dated May 4, 1987. Pre-meeting mailing June 87. Supersedes X11.1.1/86-3. Was passed to SC B in June 86. Another propsal 16.1, dated June 15, 1987 was numbered X11/SC1/TG3/87-2 and became X11/88-6. The proposal eventually became DEVICE HANDLING X11/89-4, MDC TYPE A. Post mtg July 87.

Vote

• In Washington, District of Columbia, on 5 November 1987, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept this document (also known as X11/SC1/TG3/87-2) as a Type A document of Subcommittee 1 passed by a vote of 17 in favor, none opposed and 9 abstaining.
  

X11/SC1/TG5/1986-1
Error Processing, version 4

Discussed in: SC1 Language Specification
Proposer: Mark V. Berryman
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1988-44, Error Processing, version 8
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1989-7, Alternative Error Trapping
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-2, Error Processing, version 10
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-13, Error Processing, version 11
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-75, Error Processing, version 12
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-43, Error Processing, version 13
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-55, Error Processing, version 14
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-81, Error Processing, version 15
Superseded by: X11/SC15/TG1/1991-1, Error Processing, version 16
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1991-16, Error Processing, version 17B
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-3, Error Processing, version 18
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-19, Error Processing, version 19
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-27, Error Processing, version 20
Superseded by: X11/1993-5, Error Processing, version 21
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1986
Description:
Error Processing proposal from the Task Group dated Sept 5,6, 1986. This version 4 supersedes X11.1.1/85.24. Superseded by MDC-31.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87.

X11/SC7/1986-1
Minutes Subcommittee 7, September 1986

Discussed in: SC7 Networking and Communications
Proposer: Peter M. Kuzmak
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 1986
Description:
Minutes of the meeting on Sept 9-10, 1986.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87.

X11.1/1987-1
Standard MUMPS Functions

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: David B. Brown
Superseded by: X11/SC8/1990-2, Guidelines for Library Functions

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Suggestion for a set of Standard MUMPS Functions or subroutines. "Significant interest" expressed at June 87 SC1 meeting. Document number changed from MDC-1 to X11.1/87-1.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87. Post mtg July 87.

MDC-2
S[et] $E[xtract] PseudoFunction, version 1

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Richard F. Walters
Superseded by: X11/1990-2, S[et] $E[xtract] PseudoFunction, version 6
Superseded by: X11/1992-53, S[et] $E[xtract] PseudoFunction, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1987
Description:
The original $EXTRACT proposal, dated Sept 25, 1986, that eventually became X11/SC1/89-15. Similar to (and supersedes ?) part of X11.1/86-11. Superseded by version 2, X11/SC1/87-38.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87.

Vote

• In Seattle, Washington, on 15 May 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept this document (also known as X11/SC1/89-15) as a Type A document of Subcommittee 1 passed unanimously.
  

MDC-3
Bitmap Function

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Richard F. Walters
Superseded by: X11/SC13/TG9/1994-1, Bit Manipulation, version 2

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Dated Sept 25, 1986. Proposal for a $BIT function which is to be used to set and read individual bits or fields in a string. JUNE 92: referred to SC13/TG2.
Published:
Jun 1987

MDC-5
Vector Implementation

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: R. Chris Richardson
Discussion

Submitted: 1987
Description:
A proposed change in the MUMPS data reference syntax to provide more "Relational Concept" into databases. JUNE 92: referred to SC13, 15, and Chris Richardson. JUNE 94: referred back to Chris Richardson. SEPT 96: referred to SC13/TG14.
Published:
Jun 1987
Apr 1997

MDC-6
Name Handling

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Mark A. Wieder
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1989-26, NAME
Superseded by: X11/1989-27, $NA[me] Function, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Dated Sept 23, 1986. Updated proposals for several name handling functions, without which the $QUERY function has limited utility. This version 1 is superseded, in part, by X11/SC1/89-26.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87.

MDC-7
Pattern Match Improvement

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Harlan M. Stenn
Superseded

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Suggestion for extending the "or" idea to regular expressions. JUNE 92: referred to SC13.
Published:
Jun 1987

MDC-8
Curly Braces versus Indentation

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Harlan M. Stenn
Superseded

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Suggestion to dispense with braces and let indentation alone tell the compiler how to interpret the program. Superseded by X11.1.1/85-8
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87.

X11.1/1987-2
N[ew] $T[est]

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Harlan M. Stenn
Proposed and defeated

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Suggestion concerning the need to save certain special variables as part of a NEW context. Proposed as SC C and defeated June 87.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87. Post mtg July 87.

MDC-10
Global Variable Transfer Format

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Harlan M. Stenn
Superseded by: X11/1988-15, Transfer of Routines and Global Variables, version 3
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Proposal to adopt the Global Transfer Format suggested by Fuzzy in his proposal dated 3 November 1978 (pages 5-12) Attachment 4 in the minutes of MDC #29.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87.

MDC-12
Error Trap

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Harlan M. Stenn
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-2, Error Processing, version 10
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-13, Error Processing, version 11
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-75, Error Processing, version 12
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-43, Error Processing, version 13
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-55, Error Processing, version 14
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-81, Error Processing, version 15
Superseded by: X11/SC15/TG1/1991-1, Error Processing, version 16
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1991-16, Error Processing, version 17B
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-3, Error Processing, version 18
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-19, Error Processing, version 19
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-27, Error Processing, version 20
Superseded by: X11/1993-5, Error Processing, version 21
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Dated 7 October 1986. Suggestions for the proposed mechanism for handling error traps. Superseded by X11.1.1/85-22
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87.

MDC-13
Routine Transfer Format

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Harlan M. Stenn
Superseded by: X11/1988-15, Transfer of Routines and Global Variables, version 3
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1987
Description:
Dated 7 October 1986. Proposed adoption of the Routine Transfer Format suggested by Fuzzy in his proposal dated 3 November 1978 (pages 1-4) Attachment 4 in the minutes of MDC #29.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing June 87.

X11/SC9/1989-8
SQL2/SQL3 Working Draft

Discussed in: SC9 Bindings
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-29, SQL Binding, version 5
Superseded by: X11/1992-84, SQL Binding, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Dated February, 1989.
Comments:
Secretatiat does not have a copy of this document.

X11/SC9/1989-11
Subcommittee 9 Agenda for 4th Meeting

Discussed in: SC9 Bindings
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Dated 28 March 89.
Comments:
Secretariat does not have a copy of this document.

X11/SC9/1989-18
X3.64 Binding, version 3

Discussed in: SC9 Bindings
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Superseded by: X11/SC9/1990-4, X3.64 Binding, version 4
Superseded by: X11/1990-35, X3.64 Binding, version 5
Superseded by: X11/1990-61, X3.64 Binding, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1989
Description:
A Standard binding between MUMPS and ANSI X3.64.
Comments:
Supersedes X11/SC9/89-3 and X11/SC9/89-12. Dated 6 June 89.

Vote

• In Andover, Massachusetts, on 4 October 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 9 to accept this document as a Type A document of Subcommittee 9 superseding X11/SC9/1989-12, X3.64 Binding, version 1 failed by a vote of 2 in favor, 2 opposed and 2 abstaining.
  

X11/SC9/1989-13
X Windows Draft Standard Excerpts

Discussed in: SC9 Bindings
Proposer: Robert D. Shear
Superseded by: X11/SC9/TG4/1991-1, X Window (Name) Binding
Superseded by: X11/SC9/TG4/1991-3, X Window Binding, version 1
Superseded by: X11/SC11/1992-10, X Window Binding, version 2
Superseded by: X11/1993-16, X Window Binding, version 3
Superseded by: X11/1993-25, X Window Binding, ANSI

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Dated 5 May 88.
Comments:
Secretariat does not have this document.

X11/SC9/1989-15
Subcommittee 9 TG5 Report 14 May 1989

Discussed in: SC9 Bindings
Proposer: Edward J. McIntosh
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Minutes of the X Windows Task Group, 14 May 89.

X11/SC9/1989-16
TCP Binding, version 1

Discussed in: SC9 Bindings
Proposer: Mark V. Berryman
Superseded by: X11/SC9/1990-8, TCP Binding, version 2
Superseded by: X11/SC9/1991-2, TCP Binding, version 3
Superseded by: X11/SC9/1991-5, TCP Binding, version 4
Superseded by: X11/SC14/TG6/1994-6, TCP-MUMPS Functions, version 2
Superseded by: X11/SC14/TG6/1995-1, TCP-MUMPS Binding
Superseded by: X11/SC14/TG6/1995-3, TCP/IP-MUMPS Binding
Superseded by: X11/SC14/TG6/1995-4, TCP/IP-MUMPS Mnemonics Binding
Superseded by: X11/SC14/TG6/1995-7, TCP-MUMPS Mnemonics Binding
Superseded by: X11/SC14/TG6/1995-8, Sockets-MUMPS Mnemonics Binding
Superseded by: X11/SC14/TG6/1996-3, Sockets-MUMPS mnemonics binding, version 2
Superseded by: X11/SC14/TG6/1996-4, Sockets mnemonicspace
Superseded by: X11/SC12/TG14/1997-3, Sockets binding
Superseded by: X11/SC12/1998-1, Sockets binding, version 2
Superseded by: X11/1998-14, Sockets binding, version 3

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Draft binding between Transmission Control Protocol (TCP/IP) and MUMPS. Dated 15 May 89.

X11/SC9/1989-17
Minutes Subcommittee 9, 15 May 1989

Discussed in: SC9 Bindings
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Minutes, Reports, etcetera

Submitted: 1989

Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89.

Vote

• In Andover, Massachusetts, on 4 October 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 9 to accept this document passed unanimously.
  

X11/SC1/1989-34
Device Formalization, version 2

Discussed in: SC1 Language Specification
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1989-55, Device Formalization, version 3
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-18, Device Formalization, version 4
Superseded by: X11/1990-30, Device Formalization, version 5
Superseded by: X11/1992-46, Device Handling, version 3
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Formal definition of the special variable $DEVICE. In January 88 the device handling proposal was accepted as a Type A proposal. This proposal means to formalize the definition of one of the new special variables that was introduced in device handling.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Supersedes X11/SC1/89-27. Passed to SUB B Oct 89.

Votes

• In Seattle, Washington, on 15 May 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept X11/SC1/1989-27, Device Formalization, version 1 as a Type A document of Subcommittee 1 superseding X11/SC1/TG3/1988-1, Device Handling Format failed by a vote of 8 in favor, 32 opposed and 3 abstaining.
  
• In Andover, Massachusetts, on 4 October 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept this document as a Type B document of Subcommittee 1 superseding X11/SC1/1989-27, Device Formalization, version 1 passed by a vote of 22 in favor, 8 opposed and 2 abstaining.
  

X11/1989-14
Device Handling, version 2

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Sponsor: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Superseded by: X11/1992-46, Device Handling, version 3
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1989

Published:
Sep 1989

Votes

• In Washington, District of Columbia, on 5 November 1987, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept X11.1/1987-6, Device Handling, version 1.4 (also known as X11/SC1/TG3/87-2) as a Type A document of Subcommittee 1 passed by a vote of 17 in favor, none opposed and 9 abstaining.
  
• In Washington, District of Columbia, on 10 November 1988, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to rescind X11.1.1/1985-14, Device Handling, version 1 (Provisional) passed without dissent.
  
• In Washington, District of Columbia, on 10 November 1988, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept X11/1988-6, Device Handling, version 1.7 (Definitely) (also known as X11.1/87-33) as a Type B document of Subcommittee 1 superseding X11.1.1/1985-14, Device Handling, version 1 (Provisional) passed by a majority.
  

X11/SC1/89-33A
M[erge] Command, version 1

Discussed in: SC1 Language Specification
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Superseded by: X11/1990-3, M[erge] Command, version 2
Superseded by: X11/1992-52, M[erge] Command, version 3
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Proposal to introduce a new command into MUMPS that will copy a (sub)tree into another tree. The command will be named MERGE. The syntax will look like MERGE destination=source. This supersedes X11/SC1/89-29 and changes the name from MOVE to MERGE. Superseded by X11/SC1/89-52.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Changes made at the Oct 89 meeting and then voted to SUB A.

Votes

• In Seattle, Washington, on 15 May 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept X11/SC1/1989-29, M[ove] Command Subcommittee B as a Type A document of Subcommittee 1 superseding X11/SC1/1988-45, M[ove] Command failed by a vote of 14 in favor, 23 opposed and 1 abstaining.
  
• In Andover, Massachusetts, on 4 October 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept this document as amended as a Type A document of Subcommittee 1 superseding X11/SC1/1989-29, M[ove] Command Subcommittee B passed by a vote of 41 in favor, 1 opposed and 1 abstaining.
  

X11/SC1/TG8/1989-2
External Calls, version 2

Discussed in: SC1/TG8 External Routine Interface
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Superseded by: X11/SC1/TG8/1989-3, External Calls, version 3
Superseded by: X11/SC1/TG8/1990-1, External Calls, version 4
Superseded by: X11/SC1/TG8/1990-2, External Calls, version 5
Superseded by: X11/SC1/TG8/1990-3, External Calls, version 6
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-17, External Calls, version 7
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-33, External Calls, version 8
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-69, External Calls, version 9
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1991-10, External Calls, version 10
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-12, External Calls, version 11
Superseded by: X11/SC15/1992-30, External Calls, version 12
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Modify the DO command, extrinsic variables and extrinsic functions in such a way that both MUMPS and non-MUMPS code may be called using the same mechanism.
Comments:
Combines and supersedes X11/SC1/TG8/89-1 and X11/SC1/89-28. Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Failed to move to SUB A, Oct 89.

Votes

• In Arlington, Texas, on 23 February 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept X11/SC1/TG8/1989-1, External Interface as a Type A document of Subcommittee 1 failed by a vote of 11 in favor, 26 opposed and 6 abstaining.
  
• In Andover, Massachusetts, on 4 October 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept this document as a Type A document of Subcommittee 1 superseding X11/SC1/TG8/1989-1, External Interface and X11/SC1/1989-28, External Calls, version 1 failed by a vote of 13 in favor, 26 opposed and 4 abstaining.
  

X11/SC1/1989-35
External Calls, Counterproposal, version 1

Discussed in: SC1 Language Specification
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Withdrawn

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Modify the DO command, extrinsic variables and extrinsic functions in such a way that both MUMPS and non-MUMPS code may be called using the same mechanism. This is an alternative proposal to X11/SC1/TG8/89-2. A revised version of this proposal is X11/SC1/89-51.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Failed to replace X11/SC1/TG8/89-2 at the Oct 89 meeting.

Vote

• In Andover, Massachusetts, on 4 October 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept this document as a Type A document of Subcommittee 1 failed by a vote of 13 in favor, 26 opposed and 4 abstaining.
  

X11/SC8/1989-2
$TR[anslate] Function, Variable-Length REPLACE, version 1

Discussed in: SC8 Library
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Superseded by: X11/SC8/1989-18, $TR[anslate] Function, Variable LNGTH-REPLACE, version 2
Superseded by: X11/SC8/1991-10, Library Function REPLACE, version 4
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1991-5, Library Function REPLACE, version 5
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1992-14, Library Function REPLACE, version 6
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1992-38, Library Function REPLACE, version 7
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1993-6, Library Function REPLACE, version 8
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1993-34, Library Function REPLACE, version 9
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1993-54, Library Function REPLACE, version 10
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1994-3, Library Function REPLACE, version 11
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1994-18, Library Function REPLACE, version 12
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1994-30, Library Function REPLACE, version 13
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1994-42, Library Function REPLACE, version 14
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1995-5, Library Function REPLACE, version 15
Superseded by: X11/1995-112, Library Function REPLACE, version 16
Superseded by: X11/SC8/1990-4, Library Function REPLACE, version 3

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Proposal defines two new library functions to be used for the replacemant of substrings within strings.
Comments:
Supersedes X11/SC1/88-20 and X11/SC1/89-30 and is related to X11/SC8/89-3. Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Passed to SUB B Oct 89.

Vote

• In Washington, District of Columbia, on 10 November 1988, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to remand X11/SC1/1988-20, Natural Language Handling, version 2 to Task Group superseding X11/SC1/1988-6, Natural Language Handling, version 1 passed without dissent.
  

X11/SC8/1989-3
$TR[anslate] Function, Variable-Length PRODUCE, version 1

Discussed in: SC8 Library
Proposer: Ed J.P.M. de Moel
Superseded by: X11/SC8/1989-17, $TR[anslate] Function, Variable-Length PRODUCE, version 2
Superseded by: X11/SC8/1990-3, Library Function PRODUCE, version 3
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1991-14, Library Function PRODUCE, version 5
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1992-13, Library Function PRODUCE, version 6
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1992-37, Library Function PRODUCE, version 7
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1993-5, Library Function PRODUCE, version 8
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1993-33, Library Function PRODUCE, version 9
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1993-53, Library Function PRODUCE, version 10
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1994-4, Library Function PRODUCE, version 11
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1994-17, Library Function PRODUCE, version 12
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1994-29, Library Function PRODUCE, version 13
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1994-41, Library Function PRODUCE, version 14
Superseded by: X11/SC13/1995-4, Library Function PRODUCE, version 15
Superseded by: X11/1995-111, Library Function PRODUCE, version 16

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Proposal defines two new library functions to be used for replacement of substrings within strings.
Comments:
Supersedes X11/SC1/88-20 and X11/SC1/89-30 and is related to X11/SC8/89-2. Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Passed to SUB B Oct 89.

X11/SC1/1989-37
Change Limitations on Subscripts, version 1

Discussed in: SC1 Language Specification
Proposer: Susan Schluederberg
Sponsor: Susan Schluederberg
Superseded by: X11/SC1/TG18/1990-1, Change Limitations on Subscripts, version 2
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-72, Change Limitations on Subscripts, version 3
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-45, Change Limitations on Subscripts, version 4
Superseded by: X11/1991-23, Change Limitations on Subscripts, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Proposed change in portability requirements to change the limits of subscripts.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Passed to SUB C in Oct 89. SC1/TG18 created.

Vote

• In Andover, Massachusetts, on 4 October 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept this document as a Type C document of Subcommittee 1 passed by a vote of 29 in favor, 9 opposed and 3 abstaining.
  

X11/SC1/1989-38
Significant Digits, version 1

Discussed in: SC1 Language Specification
Proposer: Susan Schluederberg
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-34, Significant Digits, version 2
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-71, Significant Digits, version 3
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-107, Significant Digits, version 4
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-44, Significant Digits, version 5
Superseded by: X11/1991-22, Significant Digits, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Proposed change to portability requirements to increase the number of significant digits to 15.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Passed to SUB C in Oct 89. Pre-mtg mailing Dec 89.

Votes

• In Andover, Massachusetts, on 4 October 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept this document as a Type C document of Subcommittee 1 passed by a vote of 34 in favor, 3 opposed and 1 abstaining.
  
• In San Francisco, California, on 26 January 1990, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to withdraw this document passed without dissent.
  

X11/SC1/1989-39
Nesting, version 1

Discussed in: SC1 Language Specification
Proposer: Susan Schluederberg
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-11, Nesting, version 2
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-70, Nesting, version 3
Superseded by: X11/1990-60, Nesting, version 4
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-1, RMDS, version 5
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-3, RMDS, version 6
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1993-6, RMDS, version 7
Superseded by: X11/TG6/1994-1, RMDS, version 9
Superseded by: X11/1996-4, ANSI/MDC X11.1-1995

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Proposed change to portability requirements to increase the levels of nesting to 120.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. To SUB C in Oct 89. Pre-mtg mailing Dec 89.

Votes

• In Andover, Massachusetts, on 4 October 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept this document as a Type C document of Subcommittee 1 passed by a vote of 36 in favor, 1 opposed and 4 abstaining.
  
• In San Francisco, California, on 26 January 1990, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept this document as amended as a Type B document of Subcommittee 1 passed by a vote of 37 in favor, none opposed and 2 abstaining.
  

X11/SC1/1989-40
Duplicate References in Parameter Passing

Discussed in: SC1 Language Specification
Proposer: Susan Schluederberg
Proposed and defeated

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Proposed change for the elimination of call by reference duplication in parameter passing.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Not passed to SUB C Oct 89.

X11/SC1/1989-41
The Effect of C[lose] $I[o], version 1

Discussed in: SC1 Language Specification
Proposer: Susan Schluederberg
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-12, The Effect of C[lose] $I[o], version 2
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-69, The Effect of C[lose] $I[o], version 3
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1990-108, The Effect of C[lose] $I[o], version 4
Superseded by: X11/SC1/1991-46, The Effect of C[lose] $I[o], version 5
Superseded by: X11/SC12/1992-27, The Effect of C[lose] $I[o], version 6
Superseded by: X11/SC12/1993-33, The Effect of C[lose] $I[o], version 7

Submitted: 1989
Description:
The effect of CLOSE $IO.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Passed to SUB C in Oct 89.

Vote

• In Andover, Massachusetts, on 4 October 1989, a motion before Subcommittee 1 to accept this document as amended as a Type C document of Subcommittee 1 passed without dissent.
  

X11/1989-15
Evolution of MUMPS

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Richard G. Davis
Administrative

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Managing the Evolution of MUMPS Technology in the 1990's. Background, Organization, and Strategy.
Comments:
Proposal that Dr. Richard Davis, and Thomas Salander presented to DOD and IHS in August 89.

X11/1989-16
Letter from Epic Re: Membership

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Daniel Bormann
Membership

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Membership application letter. Dated July 24, 1989.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89.

X11/1989-17
Subcommittee 3 Change Name and Scope of Work

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Superseded by: X11/1991-33, MDC Reorganization

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Proposed change to MDC Constitution concerning Subcommittee 3 name and scope of work. Dated August 30, 1989.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Passed Oct 89.

Vote

• In Andover, Massachusetts, on 4 October 1989, a motion before the full MDC to accept this document passed as a constitutional change superseding X11/SC3/1988-3, Documentation Subcommittee passed by a vote of 24 in favor, 1 opposed and 2 abstaining.
  

X11/1989-18
Subcommittee Bylaws Change

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Gretchen L. Bradfield
Withdrawn

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Proposed change in the MDC Constitution concerning subcommittee bylaws. Dated August 30, 1989.
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89.

X11/1989-19
Canvass Comments Henry G. Heffernan

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Henry G. Heffernan
Superseded by: X11/1990-69, ANSI Standard Approval 11/12/90

Submitted: 28 Jul 1989
Description:
Comments concerning the canvass procedures for the proposed MUMPS Standard. Dated August 25, 1989. Superseded by X11/90-7
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Part of 10/4/90 submission to ANSI by MDC. Post-mtg Nov90.

X11/1989-20
Canvass Comments Thomas C. Salander

Discussed in: MDC the MUMPS Development Committee
Proposer: Thomas C. Salander
Superseded by: X11/1990-69, ANSI Standard Approval 11/12/90

Submitted: 1 Sep 1989
Description:
Letter to MDC concerning Henry Heffernan's August 25, 1989 comments about the canvass procedures. Dated Sept 1, 1989. Superseded by X11/90-7
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Part of 10/4/90 submission to ANSI by MDC. Post-mtg Nov90.

X11/SC1/TG6/1989-1
Canvass Objection Henry G. Heffernan

Discussed in: SC1/TG6 Ansi Submission
Proposer: Henry G. Heffernan
Superseded by: X11/1990-69, ANSI Standard Approval 11/12/90

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Henry Heffernan's objection to the proposed MUMPS standard for 1989. Superseded by X11/90-7
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Review of these objections from the Canvass Submission Task Group are X11/SC1/TG6/89-2.

X11/SC1/TG6/1989-2
Canvass Response Henry G. Heffernan

Discussed in: SC1/TG6 Ansi Submission
Proposer: Thomas C. Salander
Superseded by: X11/1990-69, ANSI Standard Approval 11/12/90

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Canvass Submission Task Group response to Henry Heffernan's objection to the proposed MUMPS Standard for 1989. Superseded by X11/90-7
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89. Henry Heffernan's objection is X11/SC1/TG6/89-1.

X11/SC1/TG6/1989-3
Canvass Objection Harlan Stenn

Discussed in: SC1/TG6 Ansi Submission
Proposer: Harlan M. Stenn
Superseded by: X11/1990-69, ANSI Standard Approval 11/12/90

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Harlan Stenn's objection to the proposed 1989 Standard. Superseded by X11/90-7
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89.

X11/SC1/TG6/1989-4
Canvass Response Harlan Stenn

Discussed in: SC1/TG6 Ansi Submission
Proposer: Thomas C. Salander
Superseded by: X11/1990-69, ANSI Standard Approval 11/12/90

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Thomas Salander response to H. Stenn's objection to the proposed MUMPS 1989 standard. Dated August 4, 1989. Superseded by X11/90-7
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89.

X11/SC1/TG6/1989-5
Canvass Objection PS

Discussed in: SC1/TG6 Ansi Submission
Proposer: Peter Sherwood
Superseded by: X11/1990-69, ANSI Standard Approval 11/12/90

Submitted: 1989
Description:
Peter Sherwood's objection to the proposed MUMPS 1989 Standard. Superseded by X11/90-7
Comments:
Pre-meeting mailing Sept 89.