P. 856 a, III, 517 a. Add: (18) 'La Fille dans la Tour,' Daymard, Vieux Chants p. rec. en Quercy, p. 174; (19) 'La belle dans la Tour,' Pas de Calais, communicated by M.G. Doncieux to Revue des Traditions populaires, VI, 603; (20) 'Belle Idoine,' Questionnaire de Folklore, public par la Société du Folklore Wallon, p. 79.
M. Doucieux has attempted a reconstruction of the text in Mélusine, V, 265 ff. He cites M. Gaston Paris as having lately pointed out a striking similitude between the first half of the French popular ballad and that of a little romance of Bele Ydoine composed in the twelfth century by Audefrois le Bastars (Bartsch, Altfranzösische Romanzen und Pastourellen, p. 59, No 57). This resemblance has, I suppose, occasioned the title of 'Belle Idoine' to be given editorially to No 20 above, for the name does not occur in the ballad.
356 b, in, 517 a. Add: 'Au Jardin des Olives,' Guillon, p. 83, 'Dessous le Rosier blanc,' Daymard, p. 171 (Les trois Capitaines). A girl feigns death to avoid becoming a king's mistress, 'Hertig Henrik och Konungen,' Lagus, Nyländska Folkvisor, I, 117, No 37.
363. E. The following is the Manuscript copy, "of some antiquity," from which E was in part constructed. (Whether it be the original or a transcript cannot be determined, but Mr. Macmath informs me that the paper on which it is written "seems about the oldest sheet in the volume.") The text was freely handled. 'Lord William' does not occur in it, but the name is found in another version which follows this.
"Scotch Ballads, Materials for Border Minstrelsy," No 146 a, Abbotsford.
The Ettrick Shepherd sent Scott the following stanzas to be inserted in the first edition at places indicated. Most of them are either absolutely base metal or very much worn by circulation. The clever contrivance for breathing (found also in G 39, H 19) and the bribing of the surgeon provoke scorn and resentment.
'Gay Gos Hawk,' "Scotch Ballads, Materials for Border Minstrelsy," No 143, No 133 a, Abbotsford; in the handwriting of James Hogg.
After 12 of ed. 1802 (E 13):
After 15 (E 16):
After 22:
After 23:
After 25:
After 30:
After 31:
After 35:
"Scotch Ballads, Materials for Border Minstrelsy," No 28 b, Abbotsford; in the handwriting of William Laidlaw.
367 b. The second edition of the Minstrelsy, 1803, II, 6, inserted 13, from Hogg's communication, substituted 22, 23, 24 of Laidlaw's (H) for 27, 28, introduced 30 of Laidlaw after 36 (all with changes), and made the consequently necessary alteration in 87.
This page most recently updated on 11-May-2011, 18:14:39. Return to main index