P. 335. D a, excepting the title and the first stanza, is in a hand not Motherwell's.
I a first appeared in the second edition of the Minstrelsy, 1803, II, 245. The "gentleman residing near Langholm," from whom Scott derived the stanzas of a modern cast, was a Mr. Beattie, of Meikledale, and Scott suspected that they might be the work of some poetical clergyman or schoolmaster: letter to W. Laidlaw, January 21, 1803, cited by Carruthers, Abbotsford Notanda, appended to R. Chambers's Life of Scott, 1871, p. 121 f.
336 b. 'Den förtrollade prinsessan,' Lagus, Nyländska Folkvisor, I, 67, No 17.
356 b. Add: D c, 122. aft.
340 a, II, 505 b, III, 505 b. Sleeping under an apple-tree. See also st. 14 of the version immediately following.
So Lancelot goes to sleep about noon under an apple-tree, and is enchanted by Morgan the Fay. Malory's Morte Darthur, bk. vi, ch. 1, ch. 3, ed. Sommer, I, 183, 186. (G.L.K.)
Communicated to Scott November 11, 1812, by Hugh Irvine, Drum, Aberdeenshire, as procured from the recitation of an old woman in Buchan: Letters, V, No 137, Abbotsford. (Not in Irvine's hand.)
The following fragment does not appear to have been among the "several recitals from tradition" used by Scott in making up his ballad. Some lines which it might be supposed to have furnished occur in the edition of 1802, issued before Scott's acquaintance with Laidlaw began.
"Scotch Ballads, Materials for Border Minstrelsy," No 27, Abbotsford; in the handwriting of William Laidlaw.
"Scotch Ballads, Materials for Border Minstrelsy," No 15. Communicated to Scott by Major Henry Hutton, Royal Artillery, 24th December, 1802, as recollected by his father "and the family:" Letters I, No 77. Major Hutton intimates that stanzas 46-49 of the first edition of 'Tamlane' ('Roxburgh was my grandfather,' ff., corresponding to I 28-32) should be struck out, and his verses inserted. But 4-12 of Hutton's stanzas belong to 'Thomas Rymer.'
'Tamlane,' "Scotch Ballads, Materials for Border Minstrelsy," No 96 a; in the handwriting of John Leyden.
This page most recently updated on 11-May-2011, 17:51:27. Return to main index