P. 301. A was communicated to C.K. Sharpe by Robert Pitcairn with the stanzas in the order printed by Sharpe. The arrangement in A would seem, therefore, to have been an afterthought of Pitcairn's. There is some slight difference of reading, also, in Pitcairn's Manuscript, and one defect is supplied. The variations in the copy sent Sharpe are (besides the order, as aforesaid) as follows:
303. C. In a copy of C sent Sharpe by Motherwell in a letter of December 6, 1824, the fourth stanza is lacking, the fifth is third.
'Knip Knap,' taken down in the summer of 1893 by Mr. Walker, of Aberdeen, at Portlethen, from the singing of an old man, as learned more than fifty years before from an old blacksmith at Dyce, near Aberdeen.
P. 300. I have serious doubts whether this offensive ballad has not been made too important; whether, notwithstanding the points noted at p. 301, it is anything more than a variety of 'The Queen of all Sluts.'
305 b. A 101. lauchty in Sharpe with a line drawn in ink through l (probably by the editor, as this is a presentation copy).
V, 213 a. Since we have Pitcairn's copy only in Sharpe's handwriting, we cannot determine which of the two made the changes.
305 b, notes, 101. tauchty, etc. Drop.
303, D 5, taipy-tapples. The Manuscript has saipy-sapples.
This page most recently updated on 30-May-2011, 13:08:21. Return to main index